Which Comes First: Planer or Jointer?- Question of the Week
October 24, 2007 | Filed Under Blog, Question of the Week
This week’s question comes from Doug. He writes:
Hi Marc. I only have the money to buy one tool at a time with months in between purchases. If you were going to choose between a planer and jointer, which one would come first?
And here was my reply:
“Hey Doug. Excellent question. If I had to pick, I would get the planer first. That way you can at least get your lumber pretty darn close to flat and parallel. Furthermore you can resize your lumber when necessary. These days, i would be lost without both the jointer AND the planer. So sad.”
But that’s just my opinion. I think Doug would be best served hearing everyone’s opinions about this question. So what would you find most useful on it’s own, the planer or the jointer?
Comments
39 Responses to “Which Comes First: Planer or Jointer?- Question of the Week”
Got something to say?
-
Subscribe Now!
Via Email
Via RSS Feeds
Main Site Feed
iTunes Small Videos Large Video Feed iTunes Large Videos Wood Talk Online Feed iTunes WTO Feed
-
Support the Show
Donate
TWW Store- Tools and Supplies
Subscriptions
TWW Gear and DVDs
You can also support the show by shopping at:
Recent Comments
Bob...Las Vegas: 3:05 pm: David…thank you for sharing. It was a pleasure meeting you at the...
Claude Stewart: 1:14 pm: Nice!
jim_ny: 4:46 am: I’m just glad to see something new I like the way he works a little out of...
Vic: 9:41 pm: Is he finally past the contract with DIY. Sylvia recently took a class with Kate...
thewoodwhisperer: 3:00 pm: Hey guys. This video is very recent. I can’t remember exactly...
Germain: 2:56 pm: I saw those two videos when they were first posted on djmarks.com awhile back....
-
What's New???
-
Check this out!!
Loading the LumberJocks Widget
I would definitely agree with Marc. Although I bought my jointer first (Ridgid special from the Home of Despots), I would have most likely received more benefit from having the planer first (once again, a 13″ Ridgid special from the Home…I see a theme developing). To further the point, if you get surfaced lumber, as opposed to rough, it’s close to flat and the planer can bring it to the dimensional thickness you need. Happy woodworking.
Portland Sasquatch
I don’t have a jointer so I can’t say which way is best. I opted for a planer first due to the money issue and space!! I’m just pickier about the wood at the hardwood store since a planer can’t take out bow or twist without shims on MDF. I’ve been happy with the results so far.
Plane to get the faces parallel then use a guided circular saw to put the first straight edge on the board. Table saw to get the parallel edge then crosscut to length.
For glue-ups, I do ‘kerf jointing’ by putting the edges I’m gluing together and place the guide so the kerf takes a little off both boards. The result is a dead perfect match assuming you have a glue-edge quality blade. Once the boards are lined up, this process is pretty quick.
For the board I had a twist in (it was too nice to pass up…) the twist was abrupt so i crosscut close then did a kerf joint and the grain was luckily nearly invisible.
But now if Marc wants to lend me his 8″ jointer so I can compare experiences…
A+,
Paul-Marcel
P.S., it was good to hear Marc say “shoot some brads”
If you’re on a budget ALWAYS get hand tools first. Cheap power tools are destined for the bin, you could save yourself the disappointment, stress and frustration from trying to use them by cutting out the middleman and just throw the money away. A basic set of good quality marking, layout and hand tools, on the other hand, can be had for surprisingly little (you can also spend lots) and will always be useful, even when you’ve got as many power toys as Marc. Unfortunately it’s a whole new minefield to cross and a whole new (fast disappearing) skill set to learn which is why I’m sure Marc is planning some more hand tool friendly episodes soon.
i would also choose a planer first, you can always make a sled or something to go through your planer and get a board perfectly flat. And there is other ways to get a straight edge. Of course these techniques take more time so i would def. recommend buying a jointer in the future, but in the beginning i would get a planer.
I went for the jointer first because I had access to a friend’s portable planer. If you know someone with a planer who is close by (and nice enough to let you use it), I’d go for the jointer and get the planer afterwards. If you don’t, I’d listen to the advise above and build a jointing sled for your planer.
- Steve
I agree… With a planer sled ro side shims you can make one side pretty flat so you can have parallel sides when you do your finish thickness planing… You can side joint finish with a table saw or router (using jigs…) or with an inexpensive block plan and shooting board… I got my block plane and jack plane at a yard sale for just a few bucks and then elbow grease to clean it up and sharpen the blades… It works for me and I have planer and a jointer (Ridgid by the way…) as well…
I would go with the planer first. Most lumber suppliers will put a straight edge on a board for you for free when you buy it, and if you pick through the pile for the flatest lumber you can plane to thickness without face jointing. The lumber supplier up the street for me sells all his stuff rough planed already so its even simpler to plane it accuratly yourself (although his prices reflect the included machining).
shoot some BRADS?….
Definitely get the planer first. Although it will take longer than using a jointer, you can build a sled for your planer and joint a straight, flat face. Check out this article:
http://www.taunton.com/finewoo.....x?id=24118
and this video:
http://www.taunton.com/finewoo.....px?id=5245
Doug,
I’m asking the exact same question right now and came up with Marc’s answer. For me, the decision is based on functionality.
You can use the planer to joint. Sure, there are some hoops to jump through. But compared to buying two tools at once, those hoops seem reasonable.
You can’t use the jointer to plane. You can try, but you can’t get the two faces in plane with each other.
So, you have 2.0 needs. The planer fits 1.5 of the needs. The jointer fits 1.0 of the needs. And I figure trying to use the planer to joint wood will simply make me understand the tool that much better.
That’s how I reached the decision.
Skee
Doug,
If I were in your shoes, I would buy a planer first. This will allow you to work with rough cut boards which are a lot cheaper to buy than finished boards. As far as a jointer, I would go out to an antique store or auction or ebay and buy a #7 jointer plane. Rehab it and put a good iron in it and you will be good to go. Since I bought my LN #7 and LN #71/2 my jointer gets very little action. My first jointer plane was a Stanley #7 that I found and rehabed and it works great. I just bought the LN planes because I am on the slllliiiiiipppppeeeerrrrryyyy slope of hand planes. If you have not given hand planes a shot, try it, you’ll love it. If you need any help with rehabing an old plane or getting started, let me know, I’ll help you all I can.
I had the same dilemna when I started out (not long ago) fortunately my wife let me buy both at the same time (a 12 1/2″ Dewalt planer and the Delta 6″ benchtop planer (not so happy with)) so my problem was solved. However, when faced with this question, i’d have to agreee with Marc and get the planer first and here’s why:
In the normal process of dimensioning lumber you normally joint a face flat first and then plane the opposite side. This can be done with a planer only by building yourself a sled out of say 3/4″ mdf. You lay your lumber with the cupped face up and shim under the high points. The sled should have a stop block or use double faced tape to keep your lumber from sliding on the sled. Once you have the “top” flat, you can flip it over and run it through the planer. This may not be as convenient as running it across a nice Powermatic 8″ jointer like some lucky individuals (who shall remain nameless but who initials are Marc Spagnolo) but it works in a pinch.
I would agree with Marc, a simple jig set up on the table saw will give you straight and parallel edges. A simple router jig or planner sled jig will give you the first smooth face so that your planner can parallel off of it to create your second flat and smooth surface. Enjoy your woodworking
I agree–get the planer first. With some elbow grease and a hand plane, one can flatten one side of a board and then run it through the planer. I have a 6″ jointer and still have to use this method on larger pieces of stock that won’t fit on the jointer. Its a good technique that’s easy to learn.
GSYoung
I bought my jointer first just because it was a offer I could not refuse, and I thought that if I was careful and pay good attention that I would be able to get a flat board using a jointer. How wrong I was (thankfully on scrap peices). I think it would be a whole lot easier to flatten a board using planner than a jointer.
So I guess that makes it Planer 4 Jointer 0. I bet I see a planer in your near future.
Have fun.
Aubrey
Ridgecrest, Ca.
I have both and had the jointer first. My experience says if Doug does a lot of general woodworking, get the planer first. If he specializes in doing things that require a lot of edge glueing, then the planer should come first. Rigid makes a decent planer that includes the stand and 2 sets of blades.
Be aware, you can get by with not having a vacuum system with a jointer, but I’d say NOT with a planer.
I have to agree with Marc on this. I’ve never had a jointer and don’t really feel the need to get one in a hurry. I use a lot of reclaimed timber and the planer (we call them thicknessers down here) has paid for itself dozens of times over. I doubt if I’d have got as good value for money from a jointer (planers down here :) )
You can (with a well made jig or two), straighten twisted or bowed boards on a planer, but try getting parallel faces on a jointer and see how far you get.
Bottom line is I can live without a jointer, but I feel a planer is essential.
I would opt for the planer first and build a sled for it. It will allow you level out the material and complete the face planning that you would normally do on a jointer. The edge jointing can be done several ways, but a router table would be my first choice (something else that you can build).
If you are really tight on money and/or space you can actually complete all these functions with a router and a few jigs. They wouldn’t be nearly as fast as a jointer / planer combination, but they will get the job done.
Take it from someone in your place I found a great used Delta Planer. for little money on one of the local for sale pages. and I still don’t have a jointer but i can make do. I have my own sawmill so the planer comes in big time handy. I can mill my own lumber and move right into building. Sorry I’m going on. Just get the planer first you wont regret it
Jim
Like most people have said… planar first, jointer second. But if you are serious about woodworking, and think this will be a lifetime hobby, take a look at one of these…
http://www.newwoodworker.com/r.....12rvu.html
This Jointer-Planar combo has a couple real advantages. One machine takes up less space (important in my soon to be shop). And you only have to buy one tool… One expensive tool!!, but one really nice tool. And wouldn’t we all like to have a jointer with 12″ capacity!!! (And 4″ more than Marc!!!). It look’s like Jet has done a good job with this machine. Easy change over, easy operation. Any chances WMH will send you one of these for review Marc?!?
But if you are like the rest of us.. keep an eye on trader mags and craigslist for a good deal on a decent 12-13″ planar and then a good 6″ jointer.
Doug,
As far as a choice between a jointer & a planer… I first purchased a jointer & then bought a benchtop planer when the funds became available. The jointer allows me to flatten a side. From there I can square an edge on the jointer and then proceed to the tablesaw to rip another edge. Of course, at this point if I had a planer I would use it to flatten the other side.
In my case, since I did not have a planer at one time I took out my hand plane and worker the remaining side till it was parallel with the jointed side. I used winding sticks to achive this. At the same time the material was worked to achive the desired thickness.
There is a value in using hand tools. We develop our skills further and we certainly can appreciate a quality power tools when we use them.
Whatever tool you buy 1st or 2nd…shop around…you may find a variety of pricing for the same tool.
Good Luck!
Bob…Las Vegas
I’m Going to disagree with the master Marc..just because you can buy the lumber in the thickness you need but once you rip it what you goin to do? so I would buy the jointer or I would go on CraigsList.com and buy both of them Used for the price you would pay for one of them new…( It’s Kinda like buying a table saw without a fence!!!)
I purchased the jointer first. But I should have purchased the planer first. Purchase the planer first, you’ll be happier.
Cheers
I got a jointer first, but in retrospect I probably should have done my homework and gone with the planer. You can always rip boards on the table saw, but getting then down to a uniform thickness without access to a planer is next to impossible.
My opinion; get the planer first.
-Mark
I don’t think we have enough information to properly advise Doug yet. If you assume Doug has a table saw, his choice of planer or jointer may be different than if he doesn’t. The same would be true if he already has a collection of nice hand tools. The kind of wood working Doug plans on doing in the future is important also. I think our first step should be to ask Doug for an inventory of his equipment and find out what his interests are in terms of woodworking in the future.
I guess my opinion is pretty different than the consensus here because my jointer gets used on every thing I build but the planer sometimes isn’t touched. For one thing, you can pick up a perfectly usable 13″ portable planer for well under $500 so its less expensive than the smallest jointer I’d consider buying which is an 8″ (mine is a factory reconditioned DJ-20 and was around $1,400). Other 8″ ones like the Grizzly are nice and are quite a bit less, but are still over $500 for sure. Keep in mind though that if you find a killer deal on craigslist etc for a good jointer or planer, its worth just jumping and you’ll use both tools.
So much of what I have been building this year involves using sheet goods and dimensioned lumber that the jointer gets used to put a straight edge on things as well as prep for glue ups etc, whereas the planer only gets used when I’m dimensioning stock or dealing with rough material. After the last cabinet I built, I made a committment to myself to stop working with sheet goods and focus on building furniture made from solid wood so my planer will definately see more use; however, its still so much more efficient to put a flat and square side on a piece of stock even if I’m going to turn to using hand planes that I doubt I’d ever stop using my jointer. If I was working at a leisurely pace and was retired or just doing it for the love of working with hand tools, I’d feel differently, but the guys I respect like Phil Lowe, Scott Philips, etc all agree that the power tools remove the grunt work so that they can spend more time doing the work by hand that will show.
Get both, if you can, and save yourself a lot of head scratching. I got a planer way before a jointer, and as a result I found myself inventing creative ways of flattening boards. If I was to offer any recommendation, it’s to get both together. Consider buying used if you can’t afford both a planer and jointer new.
Workarounds for dimensioning lumber that I used while I had a planer but not a jointer:
- Flatten one face with hand plane, belt sander, or whatever it takes, and check your progress with a straightedge. If you have a rotary laser you might use it to check for flatness. Once one face is flat, run it through the planer with that face down. When the other face is flat, flip the board to clean up the first face. It doesn’t have to be pretty before going into the planer - just flat. It also doesn’t have to be completely flat - you just need to prevent the board from rocking as it goes through. For example, a dip in the middle is fine, because it’s not going to affect how the board goes through. This method is too slow unless you’re doing just a couple of boards.
- I have not tried this, but you might hot-glue the board onto a rider board, with wedges to keep it from rocking. Then send it through the planer to flatten one face. Once that’s done, pry it off and plane the other face.
- I have not tried this either, but the jig where you swipe your router back and forth across the whole face of the board seems like it would work. It would be slow, and has the potential to leave high spots that would mess with the planing, but I know people who swear by it. Obviously very slow.
- Edges are easy. Straighten the first edge with a hand plane. Cut second edge with table saw. Works great, and is very quick.
- Edge alternative. Straighten the first edge with a router, using a straightedge to guide the router along the board. Works really well. The bigger the router bit, the nicer the cut. Downside is that it’s hard to get this to work with a narrow board, and you have to fiddle around with the straightedge.
- Best alternative: Just give up and get a jointer to go with the planer. This is the option I recommend. While you’re at it, get a good dust collector. That one is very easy to justify with a spouse, since dust is carcinogenic.
I would advice against buying dimensioned lumber (s2s or s4s) at the home center unless you absolutely have to. You will cut your joints and then find that the whole table (or whatever you’re building) is slightly out of whack. And everything you make will be 3/4″ thick. Lumber will always move around, so unless you dimension it in your workshop and assemble it in your workshop, it’s going to bend/warp/fart in your general direction.
I am gonna go out a limb here and say this: I would buy the jointer first. Why, here is the why: making sleds for the planer is hard, they are NEVER true, can NEVER make a twisted board truely parallel. I personally would get the jointer, then make a router jig to flatten the other side, then handplane or scape the routed side smooth. This ensures one side is dead flat (a jointer wins hands down here folks), then the router jig allows me to router the other side off that flat face parallel. Easy as pie.
Of course both is the best option, and if anyone thinks otherwise, they really don’t know what they are talking about! (planer and jointer are the best).
But the advantages of the jointer (can flatten one face dead flat–this dependent on how wide the jointer is), it can make perfect straight edges for gluing-jigs for planers cannot give the consistency that jointers do for edges, you control what gets cut on the jointer (pressure, where you start the feed-planer takes that control away), and finally the jointer allows the ease of producing 90 degree corners to the flat face or even other angles for bevelling-very handy.
I am not preeching, sorry if i sound that way folks. But the jointer is really under rated these days!
thanks again
I agree with Marc about the planer first.
The places I have bought lumber from will give me one (sometimes a little rough) flat face and a right angle edge.
With the planer, I can get nice parallel flat faces and mill the board to the desired thickness. I then use my table saw to straighten up the other edge. If the board is wide enough, I can use a router with a straight edge to clean up the edge as well.
Tom
I would have to say the jointer first also because you need true edges to join pieces together. with a getting boards the same thickness that is less important to me because you can have them done at a local cabinet shop or at a saw mill for little money. I have have both now but had a jointer first and I ether flattened them buy hand with a belt sander or hand plane but also took them to my local cabinet shop and had them planed. I have to say that I use the jointer more then my planer.so that is why I would buy the jointer first.
I would first go with the jointer. You can always buy dimensioned lumber but what you can’t buy is straight edged lumber. If you trust the lumberyard to edge your boards for panel glue-ups your in trouble. If you are like Marc, and doing this for a living, then either or both is a necessity of life. In his case, time is money. For the rest of us, though, this is a hobby - buy a set of decent hand planes.
Im pretty sure you could get a good qaulity used planer/thicknesser for what you’d pay for a jointer. Kill 2 birds with 1 stone and a great space saver into the bargain.
I would get the jointer first, then after a week you’ll wish you had gotten the planer first… then get a planer. That’s how it happened to me. :)
Don’t forget to shop for used tools on CL and similar. You can often get two quality 10-year-old tools for the price of one new one. Get a copy of “Workshop Machines” by Taunton Press first if you don’t know much about shop machines.
You guys have cover it, so new question. Without worrying about space. 12in planer/jointer combo [ie., Grizzly G0633, Jet JJP-12, Rojec MSP310M] or 15in planer and 6in/8in joiner. Does the 3 in difference on the planer make that much difference because either way the cost of purchase [new] is about the same.
I would actually vote for the combo. They are really taking off in popularity and I do think you will enjoy the extra capacity for jointing.
I purchase my lumber S2S so having a jointer to flatten one side is never an issue. My big planer is a 30 YO Rockwell 24″. My portable planer is a 20 YO Ryobi 10″ that does all the small work, I love it. I can also plane rough lumber in it and it comes out flat, those little rubber rollers can’t flatten a cupped board like the big Rockwell can.
Instead of a jointer I just have a very nice, sharp blade on my small Delta TS. I rip one edge and it’s as clean and straight as a jointer could ever be.
Can someone please provide some background info on the combo planer/jointer? I’m thinking it’s a jointer that just also happens to have a wide-enough blade so that you can flatten the wide side of a board too. In the end, you can have 4 flat slides but don’t have any guarantee that the sides would be parallel to each other…??? Is this all correct?
I’m debating whether to start out with a planer (that seems to have been the most popular answer here versus a jointer) or getting a combo planer/jointer.
(continued from above)
I suppose, though, with the combo you cannot plane as wide boards as you can with a dedicated planer.
Greg. The planer/jointer is just that, a planer AND a jointer. The machine actually “transforms” from one machine to the other. So if it has 12″ blades on it, you have a 12″ jointer in one mode, and a 12″ planer in the other. And the trade-off is you get a super wide jointer, but you might be limited by the planer aspect. There are indeed some occasions when we plane things that are way wider than the capacity of our jointers. But for most shops, a 12″ planer is more than adequate. You may want to find a store that has one of these machines in stock so you can see the tool for yourself in person.